Whoopie Pies have been around for a while but have just never quite managed to live up to the hype... Probably because they're just never going to be quite as pretty as a dainty little cupcake. They're more manly - a little like the concept behind Coke Zero perhaps. But not quite manly enough to become popular with actual men.
They're an odd mix between a cake and a macaroon, and while they travel well, it's a bit of a struggle to make them look nice enough to present to someone for a special occasion. Mind you, often the novelty makes up for that.
Out of the 3 I've tried making from the Hummingbird Cake Days book, probably the nicest are the Red Velvet ones, but like all things Red Velvet they're an effort. These chocolate ones are a bit less of a faff, but still taste wunderbar. The vanilla and cardamom ones were pretty ace too - nice and chic for fancy occasions.
The sponge is surprisingly not very sweet. But the riciculously sweet innards make up for that... The icing uses Marshmallow Fluff, which, being in the UK, isn't the easiest to find. I just found some in Selfridges and got quite excited - I have used melted marshmallows in the past though and as long as theyre quite cool (add a teeny bit of water to stop them solidifying again) when you add them to the icing sugar and butter mixture it works quite well. Make sure you give it a good while in the fridge before you ice them too.
Sponge:
1 Egg
150g Caster Sugar
125g Natural Yoghurt
25ml Milk
1/4 Tsp Vanilla Essence
75g Butter, Melted
200g Plain Flour
80g Cocoa Powder
3/4 Tsp Bicarbonate of Soda
1/4 Tsp Baking Powder
Icing:
170g Butter
280g Icing Sugar
220g Marshmallow Fluff
Beat the egg and sugar until pale and fluffy, then mix the milk, yoghurt and vanilla together and chuck that in with the egg and sugar. Stir in the melted butter. Sift together the rest of the dry ingredients and add that in two batches, making sure its all mixed in. Leave to set for half an hour in the fridge.
Heat the oven to 170 degrees C, and blob the mixture onto a baking sheet covered in greaseproof paper (which is definitely necessary). Make the blobs any size you want, the only important thing is to keep them all the same size and shape so they fit together when they're cooked - I like them quite small. Tiny bite-size ones would be great for a party - the less effort to get them in your gob (without getting crumbs all down your gown) the better I say.
Cook until they're springy on top (10-15 minutes).
For the icing, mix the icing sugar and butter until well combined then stir in the Marshmallow fluff. If you've got a machine (or someone you can use as a machine) this is good as it is much easier said than done. Marshmallow fluff is shockingly stiff. Who knew sugar could be so unforgiving. If you don't have a machine to hand, it is possible to do this by hand, and if done on a regular basis works nicely towards that Rafael Nadal look (check out his arms if you don't know what I mean...).
The icing will probably now be stiff enough to prop up the majority of your kitchen cutlery - if it isn't, pop it in the fridge for a bit.
Then all that is left is to sandwich two chocolate blobs together with some of the icing. Don't be shy with the icing - there is a LOT here. I also like to spread some jam on one side too to liven them up a bit.
Happy Whoopie.